or Create a profile
06 Oct, 2015 02:21 PM
I came across criticmarkup about a year ago, and instantly found that it was a good idea. I had been trying to come up with a similar solution for my own private work. However, I found some aspects of the syntax a bit troublesome. I realise that once these things are adopted there isn't much to do about it, and so far I just haven't bothered using it, but it occurred to me that I should let someone know.
To me, the greatest value of criticmarkup is to be follow the principle of markdown, namely to be "publishable as-is, as plain text, without looking like it’s been marked up with tags or formatting instructions."
As it stands, I find the criticmarkup syntax hugely distracting in a text. It is very difficult to actually read the marked up text.
I find that the more characters are added, the more cluttered it becomes. Criticmarkup uses 6 characters to indicate a comment:
To me, the added value then is non-existent to just using an HTML comment:
Ideally, using only 2 characters should be enough:
I realise curly braces probably make for easy parsing and fewer conflicts, but one can make do with something a bit more minimal:
So I hope you will forgive me, but for now I have chosen to pass on criticmarkup, instead using my own scheme for tracking changes and commenting on my text.
on 16 Feb, 2016 02:31 AM
You complain about Criticmarkup comments using 6 characters, but the HTML comment uses 7 characters. Not a very convincing argument.
on 25 Feb, 2016 08:41 AM
In case I didn't make my case clear, I don't think html comments are better in this respect. 7 or 6 characters just doesn't make much of a difference to me.
However, using only 2-3 characters would make a big difference.
on 25 Feb, 2016 08:57 AM
The reason I used the html comment as an example is that markdown is made to be significantly easier to read and write than html, and so it seems reasonable that criticmarkup should follow that ideal as well.
Formatting help /
(switch to plain text)
(switch to Markdown)
You can attach files up to 10MB
If you don't have an account yet, we need to confirm you're human and not a machine trying to post spam.
A conversation has been started with the CriticMarkup staff to resolve this discussion.
This discussion is private.
Only you and CriticMarkup support staff can see and reply to it.
This discussion is public. Everyone can see and reply to it.
You can use Command ⌘ instead of Control ^ on Mac
Powered by Tender™.